Yates County had more homes for sale at the end of September 2026 than a year earlier, even though fewer owners listed and fewer buyers closed during the summer quarter. Supply is building up among homes that are already standing. Meanwhile, Penn Yan's largest housing proposal finished 2026 smaller than it started.
Fewer listings, fewer sales, more homes for sale
The New York State Association of REALTORS publishes a county table every quarter. In its third-quarter 2026 report, current as of Oct. 10, Yates County had 86 new listings from July through September, down 15.7% from 102 in the same quarter of 2025. Closed sales for the quarter fell 10.3%, from 68 to 61. At the end of the quarter, 63 homes were for sale, up 26% from 50 a year before.
A count of homes for sale goes up when more homes come on the market or when fewer leave it. In Yates this year, fewer homes came on. So the higher count at the end of September reflects listings staying active longer.
Months' supply, the number of months current inventory would last at the recent pace of sales, shows the same thing. In the third quarter of 2026 it rose from 2.8 months to 3.9. The quarter's median sale price rose 2.9%, to $352,500. Sellers held their prices while buyers took longer to commit.
Priced near Ontario County, paced closer to Steuben
The same NYSAR table puts Yates next to the counties a buyer is probably also considering. The figures below are for the third quarter of 2026 compared with the third quarter of 2025.
| County | Q3 2026 median sale price | Change in closed sales | Homes for sale | Months' supply |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Yates | $352,500 | -10.3% | 63 | 3.9 |
| Ontario | $360,000 | +21.6% | 261 | 2.7 |
| Seneca | $228,500 | +1.3% | 61 | 2.8 |
| Wayne | $275,000 | -3.3% | 125 | 1.8 |
| Livingston | $260,000 | +19.2% | 81 | 2.0 |
| Steuben | $199,950 | +5.2% | 250 | 4.1 |
| Schuyler | $325,000 | -4.4% | 74 | 6.6 |
Ontario County is the closest comparison. Its quarterly median was within $7,500 of Yates. But Ontario's new listings rose 11.9% and its closed sales rose 21.6%. More homes came on the market there, and buyers took them. In Yates, fewer came on and buyers took fewer of those.
On pace, Yates sits between Seneca County at 2.8 months and Steuben County at 4.1, with Schuyler, on the other side of Seneca Lake, at 6.6. A buyer comparing Yates with Ontario County this winter is looking at similar prices and a slower pace, which means more time to decide on any one house.
Why September's 18 sales say less than the quarter
NYSAR's monthly report for September 2026 shows a sharper drop. Yates closed 18 sales that month, down 35.7%, and the median sale price fell 18.1% to $306,500.
With 18 sales, a few lakefront closings landing in August instead of September can move the median by tens of thousands of dollars. The median is just the middle sale, so in a month that small it mostly reflects which homes happened to close. The quarter's 61 sales and $352,500 median are the better read on prices. The September report also shows 30 new listings, up 7.1% from September 2025. One month of more listings does not change the quarter's pattern. If more homes keep coming on through the fall, inventory will build up faster than it did over the summer.
The 72 acres on Old Route 14A
The usual answer to a housing shortage in a small county is more construction. In Yates County, the main proposal for that construction spent most of the past two years in a dispute between the Village of Penn Yan and the Town of Milo.
The Finger Lakes Economic Development Center bought the former McFetridge Farm at 2442 Old Route 14A in 2021. The Finger Lakes Times reported that FLEDC originally planned an industrial park there. It then concluded that an industrial park would need workers, and that the area lacked enough housing for them. In 2024, FLEDC petitioned to annex the land into the village. In January 2025, the Village Board approved the annexation and the Town of Milo rejected it on the same day. Lawsuits and a town eminent domain proceeding followed.
At a 2024 public hearing, FLEDC CEO Steve Griffin described a first phase of about 39 single-family bungalows of roughly 1,400 to 1,500 square feet, plus townhomes and senior apartments. About 50 units would be affordable to entry-level wage earners, according to Finger Lakes Daily News. Griffin named Coach and Equipment, KanPak and Finger Lakes Premiere Properties as local employers that needed more workers. In January 2026, FingerLakes1.com reported that Coach and Equipment had filed a site plan for an expansion of about 66,000 square feet.
On June 22, 2026, about two weeks before a trial was set to begin, the Milo Town Board and the Penn Yan Village Board each approved a settlement, according to Finger Lakes Daily News. The farm was divided roughly in half, with about 36 acres going to the village. As reported, the agreement puts the housing on that village half at no more than 180 homes. In January 2025, the Chronicle-Express described the proposal as a 500-unit housing project.
What 180 dwellings and 16 apartments add up to
For scale, Yates County closed 61 home sales in the third quarter of 2026 alone. Even at its full size, a 180-home neighborhood would be built over time rather than arriving all at once. The 63 existing homes listed at the end of September are a supply a buyer can walk through today.
Downtown, the developer 43 North announced plans in April 2026 to turn the Struble Arcade on Main Street into 16 apartments with retail on the ground floor. Finger Lakes Daily News described the 1869 building as Penn Yan's earliest version of a shopping mall. It once housed medical offices, photography studios and a basement oyster bar with its own street entrance. The plans call for restoring the grand staircase and central skylight, rebuilding the roof and installing about 200 support beams in the basement. Sixteen apartments add to the village's housing stock, but they are a small number next to a county that sells dozens of homes each quarter.
Both projects will add to Penn Yan's housing over time. Between now and spring, though, a Yates County buyer is choosing among homes that are already built, and the summer numbers show those homes taking longer to sell.
Shopping Yates County this winter
A months' supply near four gives a buyer more to compare than in Wayne County at 1.8 or Livingston County at 2.0. It also leaves more time between a showing and an offer. A listing that has been on the market since late summer tells you how its price has held up against the county's 3.9-month pace. Asking how long a home has been listed, and how its price has changed since it went up, is the most useful question in Yates right now. The county-level figures don't separate Keuka and Seneca Lake frontage from village and farm properties, so a home-by-home read of sold history matters more here than in a county with ten times the sales.
Our Yates County guide and our earlier look at Keuka Lake's most popular home areas cover the towns themselves. For buyers who would rather build, our new construction page lists current options across the region.
A few common questions
Is the drop in Yates County's September median a sign prices are falling? September had 18 closed sales, too few for the median to mean much. The third quarter of 2026 as a whole, with 61 sales, showed a median of $352,500, up 2.9% from a year earlier.
Which Finger Lakes counties had more months of supply than Yates this summer? In the third quarter of 2026, Steuben County had 4.1 months and Schuyler County had 6.6, compared with 3.9 in Yates. Ontario, Seneca, Wayne and Livingston all had less.
How does Yates County compare with Ontario County on price? For the third quarter of 2026, Yates's median was $352,500 and Ontario's was $360,000. Ontario had 2.7 months of supply against 3.9 in Yates.
If you are weighing a Yates County home this winter and want to see how long similar Keuka, Seneca or village properties have sat before selling, Griffith Realty Group can walk you through the sold history behind any listing on your list. Contact us for a confidential consultation.